Showing posts with label Pixar. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pixar. Show all posts

Saturday, March 26, 2016

The Good Dinosaur (2015)

Director: Peter Sohn
Score: 2/10

You Tried

Once upon a time, a Disney-owned animation studio grew to the point where they wanted to put out two movies in a year instead of their normal single production.  With most of the sure money, budget, and talent focused on the A-team flick, the second-tier squad was free to make a movie free of the typical constraints of oversight, committee design, and fear of the unknown.  In the end, that movie turned out to be one of the greatest animated classics of all time.

But guess what; it’s not 1994, and this ain’t The Lion King.  In fact, it’s about as polar opposite as you could possibly get.

Let’s not beat around the bush, here: The Good Dinosaur is bad.  Dyed-in-the-wool, from-the-core-out bad, in a way I haven't seen in years.  Anything and everything that could have gone wrong with this movie did, at every level of production.  The creation was plagued with issues, including mass layoffs, directorial spats, and conflicts over story and art direction.  The film languished in an interminable six year void before finally being released, presumably because these days you could throw your vacation photo slideshow on a film screen and make your money back.  I kind of feel bad for Peter Sohn, because he ended up with his name attached to it as the leader.  Sure, maybe he got a wounded bird out the door and into the air; but that bird then was hit by a rock, burst into flames, and crashed on the shoreline where it exploded.  Suffice to say, there’s a reason the “Alan Smithee” credit was invented.

The Good Dinosaur is (I assume) the story of a cowardly young dinosaur coming of age.  Right from the beginning, though, I’m just hauled out of the moment by the insane incongruity of the film’s premise.  Why are dinosaurs somehow more evolved than mammals, to the point where they are capable of forming an agrarian society?  Why does the human... uh... cub wear clothing but is unable to do anything remotely like a human (like walking)?  Why is half the dialogue in this stupid movie made up of giggles, screams, and unintelligible grunting?!

The plot, if you can call it that, is a loosely-strung-together collection of set pieces copied from other movies (and not very well).  They even blatantly ripped off the patriarchal death scene from The Lion King in the most ham-fisted way possible, which is a shame, because as I alluded to in my opening paragraph, there’s plenty of much more useful lessons they could have gotten from that movie instead.  Everything is contrived, nothing is original, and the entire movie actually undermines itself with its own art direction.  Literally, this is alternate prehistory FANFICTION, with every negative connotation that may imply.  If it had a narrative adaptation, it would have an "and then" in between every sentence.

The sole point of any praise whatsoever I can grant The Mediocre Reptile is that the CG on the backgrounds is stunning.  Like, photo-realistic in a way I’ve never seen before.  It seriously looks like they animated cells over actual video footage of backdrops and water.  So, with that in mind and that technology in the bank, why for the love of film are all the characters so cartoony?!  It doesn’t match at all.  I actually found my mind rejecting it altogether because I couldn’t reconcile how great the scenery looked with how utterly average the actual character models and animation are.

In a way, I’m glad The Terrible Fossil came out.  First off, it gives me the chance to really rip into a movie that deserves it.  Sometimes, it’s relaxing as a critic to just shoot some mostly-dead fish in a particularly small barrel.  But beyond that, I hope this movie is the proof we finally need to get past the “But Pixar” argument.  Pixar isn’t sacrosanct; they’re just as capable of making soulless pap as any other studio is (Cars 2 neatly demonstrated that, but people like to forget that movie existed, now don’t they?)  What makes Pixar great is their approach to creating movies, starting from the very first premise.  If you make the mistake of forgetting about that approach, of approaching a movie as an obligation instead of a craft, you get—

Well, you get this, actually.

Acting: 4
Story: 1
Visuals: 6
Sound: 4
Enjoyment: 1
Overall Score: 2/10

Saturday, July 11, 2015

Inside Out (2015)

Directors: Pete Docter, Ronaldo Del Carmen
Score: 10/10

Please Do a Sequel Where You Try To Explain A First Crush, Please?

There’s a joke image going around the internet lately regarding Pixar’s brainstorming methods.  It starts with PIxar posing the thought “What if toys had feelings” in 1995, and working their way through “What if bugs had feelings” and “What if monsters had feelings”, all the way through fish, superheros, cars, rats, robots, and so on.  Well, we’ve finally come in the full-meta circle all the way to “What if feelings had feelings?”

At this point, it’s extremely tempting to point at the 94/100 metacritic score, say “It’s Pixar, how bad could it possibly be?” and knock off for dinner—but I’d like to think I’m a bit more professional than that.  Honestly, though, there’s only so many words I can use to talk directly about the movie before I start treading water.  Instead, I’d like to talk a little bit about animation.

There’s a certain sort of truth that I’ve started really noticing and putting a lot of thought into of late, and it’s the notion that animation will always be better than live action at evoking emotion and living deeply in your memories.  Toy Story was TWENTY years ago, and most of us can still remember that movie, if not exactly when we first saw it and how we felt at the time.  Can you remember a live-action movie from the same year?  Did it make you feel anything like Toy Story did?  I wasn’t even in middle school at the time, and that movie is still quite fresh in my mind, when I’ve forgotten most of the names of the people I knew back then.

That’s the power of animation, and that’s what Pixar has done a masterful job of grasping: animation is the stuff of emotions.  Aspects of characters can be selectively diminished or enhanced with subtle graphical differences.  The drawings become caricatures without being forced into cliche or stereotype.  Everyone instinctively knows something about the character when you draw them as short and squat, or wispy beyond realism, or as an anthropomorphized object.  It’s storytelling shorthand.

So why does Pixar seem to have this formula down to a science?  Why do Disney/Pixar creations account for four of the only six movies I’ve ever cried at, or even come close to crying at?  What do they know that the rest don’t?

Inside Out is a prime example of what makes Pixar great: every element serves to drive the story’s central idea.  Their central writing tenants almost dictate it.  Heck, look up their “22 Rules of Story” sometime—it’s almost my personal Bible for writing fiction.  There’s no fat, no wasted energy on joke characters or throwaway “humor” in a misguided attempt to hold a child’s attention.  That sort of audience-degrading thought is what drug down something like Frozen.  Kids aren’t stupid.  They have deep feelings that they can’t always put words to.  Kids are complex, perhaps even more complex than adults are sometimes.  Inside Out captures all of these truths and more.  It handles something as utterly abstract and indescribable as depression, and never takes its audience for granted.  It’s smart enough for the adults, and accessible enough for anyone.

Does it have the utter staying power of something like the original Toy Story or (one of my personal favorites) How to Train Your Dragon 2?  I don’t know.  I think that might rely more on where you are and how old you are when you see it.  Personally, I don’t know if I’d promote Inside Out to my personal best-ever list, but by my own description of what the scores I give mean, there’s just nothing else to give it but a 10/10.  I left the theater with all the feels, and I bet you might, too.

Acting: 10
Story: 9
Visuals: 9
Sound: 8
Enjoyment: 10
Overall Score: 10/10