Showing posts with label Oscar-Winner. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Oscar-Winner. Show all posts

Friday, July 10, 2015

A Beautiful Mind (2001)

Director: Ron Howard
Score: 5/10

The Head Eats The Tail:  Hollywood Biopics

This was a very overdue viewing for me.  I’ve known about this film for years, from the fact that it was a breakout movie for director Ron Howard, its starring Russell Crowe, and even the fact that it did very well at the Oscars.  Somehow, though, it always fell to the back of my “to-see” list.  Maybe just because I was busying reveling in similar classics, the way Megamind was largely overshadowed by the too-similar Despicable Me.  I dunno.

A Beautiful Mind follows the life’s story of John Nash, an utterly brilliant mind that helped change the way we view not only social theory, but video games, conflict resolution, societal mores, and economics (for which he won his Nobel prize).  As is often the case, however, a mind like that comes with baggage.  In Nash’s case, it was a growing battle with schizophrenia, blooming into full-blown paranoia.  He feared communists, and was actually convinced that everyone in a red tie was out to get him (sadly not depicted in the film).  In the end, he fought and largely won a battle with the disease, and contributed greatly to society through his teaching, research, and theories.

Sadly, I feel more than a little regret at my lapse in viewing this film, because I honestly feel like this is a movie I would have enjoyed much more two or three years ago.  As it stands now, I see it as largely just average.

Let’s not leave things unsaid, though, A Beautiful Mind does some things very well indeed.  The sheer force of directing needed to adequately show and audience the effects of schizophrenia and the accompanying confusion, dementia, and angst is just staggering to think about.  The film’s score is very good, seemingly weaving in and out of musical themes in much the same way our protagonist’s mind does with reality.  The Oscar for best supporting actress is much deserved as well.

The problem is with biopics in general of late.  Hollywood has poisoned itself in my mind.  I fear that I’ve been largely ruined on the biographical-film genre thanks to films like The Imitation Game and American Sniper, two of the most disingenuous films I think I’ve ever watched.  I watched A Beautiful Mind throughout with Wikipedia open on my phone, fact-checking the movie as I saw it.  At the credits, my thought of “that’s a pretty decent movie” was closely shadowed by “I wonder how much of it was a lie?”

I’m not ignorant, I know that the words “based on a true story” have always been free license to an Oscar-baiting director, but I used to be able to overlook that.  Maybe it’s the free, instantaneous access to information in this age that throws such a blinding light on the ways films twist historical facts into a story, or maybe it’s simply a cynicism born of age and maturity in a movie-goer who is actually passingly familiar with the names and persons on the screen beforehand.  Maybe ignorance really is bliss.  Who can say?  Movie writers have gone to the well too many times, and now I find myself dry as I watch.

All I know is that in my mind, I find myself comparing A Beautiful Mind to the likes of, say, Good Will Hunting (I’m not 100% sure why, maybe it’s the visual aesthetic, or the way both films deal with inherent brilliance in a character).  I find the fictional story not only more palatable, but infinitely deeper and more meaningful.  Maybe that’s really where the crux of the issue lies: the real story isn’t necessarily a good story.  Be that as it may, I’d much rather have a story that’s based on a fact or a historical event rather than a real person.  I don’t enjoy having someone’s real flaws traded for ones that are more subservient to a plot.

Acting: 8
Story: 5
Visuals: 6
Sound: 7
Enjoyment: 5
Overall Score: 5/10

Tuesday, May 26, 2015

Whiplash (2014)

Director: Damien Chazelle
Score: 9/10

When Good Art Isn’t Enjoyable Art

Let’s get one thing out of the way right now, spoilers aside: Whiplash is NOT an enjoyable movie to watch.  It’s painful, and disturbing, and often causes you to flip-flop on exactly who you’re rooting for and sympathetic to across the course of the movie.

What is is, though, is fantastic art and brilliant visual storytelling.

For a first-time director, Damien Chazelle had one hell of a vision in his head when he wanted to make Whiplash.  Originally an unfunded short film that swept Sundance in 2013, Chazelle got funding for a full-length version of the film almost overnight.  He definitely got the right cast, too.

The story follows Andrew Neyman (Miles Teller) during his first year in a prestigious music college.  The kid has chops, there’s no way to deny that.  Teller did his own drumming for the film, and it’s some of the greatest musicality I’ve ever seen committed to a movie.  He’s on the rise, and he thinks his break has arrived when he catches the eye of Fletcher (played by an unnervingly intense J.K. Simmons), a mad genius of a music teacher who leaves a trail of broken and disillusioned musicians in his wake as he searches for the next great among all greats.

Fletcher is abusive, tyrannical, manipulative, conniving, and just downright evil, to the point where you wonder why he ever got a teaching position at all—but then you see the results.  You see how he can push people beyond the limits of what they ever thought they could achieve.  You also see the sad and horrible results of what happens when the student can’t live up to his standards.  J.K. Simmons said in interviews that the purpose of this film’s ending is "to inspire discussion and debate and not decide - are we happy for Andrew Neyman or are we lamenting his loss of humanity. The debate I love, is how far is too far? How much is too much? Is it worth it?”

This movie is brilliant, I can’t say that enough.  It stormed into the Academy Awards, winning three categories when it wasn’t really considered a lock to even get more than one nomination.  The directing is genius, and the scope of the film’s story encompasses every detail, from camera work (which is energetic and forceful) to the protagonist’s backstory (he idolizes Buddy Rich, which is a fairly significant foreshadowing) to the wardrobe (which actually has some major weight to it as a metaphor for the power struggles going on throughout the movie).  The sound design is purposeful, mixing live drumhits alongside studio-track mastering of the music (which is stunning).  Seriously, if you enjoy anything about music and the performance of music, you will be slack-jawed at that aspect, if nothing else.  There has very likely never been another music film which hits you with such intensity and with such a ruthless dramatic edge as this.

When it’s all said and done, this is not an enjoyable movie.  Every character is deep and well-rounded, sure, but no one is particularly sympathetic.  If the writer/director hadn’t done such a good job at making the characters’ motivations and passions such integral parts of the characters, I’d most likely be ranting about how poor the movie is.  What this movie is is a work to be studied; to be dissected and measured, and what we learn from that dissection is that this movie lives up to the hype.

Whiplash is fantastic art, and it deserves to be celebrated for it.

Acting: 9
Story: 7
Visuals: 8
Sound: 10
Enjoyment: 6
Overall Score: 9/10